As of February 1, 2025, Pete Alonso remains a free agent, with ongoing negotiations and speculations about his future in Major League Baseball (MLB). Alonso, who debuted with the New York Mets in 2019, has been a significant offensive contributor, leading the National League in home runs and RBIs over the past six seasons. His free agency has been a focal point of the offseason, with various reports detailing contract offers, rejections, and potential landing spots.
Contract Negotiations with the New York Mets
The New York Mets have been proactive in their attempts to retain Alonso. They reportedly offered him a three-year contract valued between $68 million and $70 million, which Alonso declined. This offer was notably less than a previous seven-year, $158 million extension proposed in 2023, which Alonso also turned down. The Mets’ reluctance to commit to a longer-term deal, especially for a player entering his 30s, aligns with team president David Stearns’ cautious approach to long-term contracts for players in this age bracket.
Mets owner Steve Cohen has expressed his frustration with the protracted negotiations, describing them as “exhausting.” He emphasized the challenges of fitting Alonso into an already expensive roster and indicated that the team is prepared to move forward without him if an agreement cannot be reached. Despite this, Cohen acknowledged Alonso’s significant contributions to the team and the desire among fans for his return.
Speculations and Predictions
The uncertainty surrounding Alonso’s future has led to various speculations. WFAN radio host Boomer Esiason confidently predicted that Alonso would re-sign with the Mets on a specific Friday, a prediction that did not materialize, leaving fans disappointed.
MLB insider Ken Rosenthal suggested that a short-term, high-value contract might be a feasible solution for both parties. He proposed a three-year deal worth approximately $90 million, which would set a record for average annual value (AAV) for a first baseman. This structure could provide Alonso with substantial earnings while allowing him to re-enter free agency in his early 30s.
Interest from Other Teams
Alonso’s free agency has attracted interest from several teams. The San Francisco Giants have been mentioned as a potential suitor, given their recent efforts to sign top-tier free agents. However, Oracle Park’s reputation as a pitcher-friendly stadium may deter power hitters like Alonso.
The Los Angeles Angels reportedly offered Alonso a two-year, $50 million deal, which he declined. Alonso and his agent, Scott Boras, are believed to be seeking a higher annual value, potentially around $31 million per season.
Fan Reactions and Future Outlook
Fans are divided over Alonso’s contract rejections. Some believe he is overestimating his market value, while others feel the Mets should make a more substantial effort to retain their homegrown star. Alonso’s consistent performance, including averaging nearly 38 home runs over his first six seasons and his durability—missing only 24 games in that span—underscore his value.
As the offseason progresses, the outcome of Alonso’s free agency remains uncertain. The Mets have made roster moves, such as signing Jesse Winker and A.J. Minter, and are preparing younger players to potentially fill the first base position. Alonso’s decision will significantly impact the Mets’ lineup and could influence the dynamics of the National League in the upcoming season.
As of February 1, 2025, Pete Alonso remains a free agent, with ongoing negotiations and speculations about his future in Major League Baseball (MLB). Alonso, who debuted with the New York Mets in 2019, has been a significant offensive contributor, leading the National League in home runs and RBIs over the past six seasons. His free agency has been a focal point of the offseason, with various reports detailing contract offers, rejections, and potential landing spots.
Contract Negotiations with the New York Mets
The New York Mets have been proactive in their attempts to retain Alonso. They reportedly offered him a three-year contract valued between $68 million and $70 million, which Alonso declined. This offer was notably less than a previous seven-year, $158 million extension proposed in 2023, which Alonso also turned down. The Mets’ reluctance to commit to a longer-term deal, especially for a player entering his 30s, aligns with team president David Stearns’ cautious approach to long-term contracts for players in this age bracket.
Mets owner Steve Cohen has expressed his frustration with the protracted negotiations, describing them as “exhausting.” He emphasized the challenges of fitting Alonso into an already expensive roster and indicated that the team is prepared to move forward without him if an agreement cannot be reached. Despite this, Cohen acknowledged Alonso’s significant contributions to the team and the desire among fans for his return.
Speculations and Predictions
The uncertainty surrounding Alonso’s future has led to various speculations. WFAN radio host Boomer Esiason confidently predicted that Alonso would re-sign with the Mets on a specific Friday, a prediction that did not materialize, leaving fans disappointed.
MLB insider Ken Rosenthal suggested that a short-term, high-value contract might be a feasible solution for both parties. He proposed a three-year deal worth approximately $90 million, which would set a record for average annual value (AAV) for a first baseman. This structure could provide Alonso with substantial earnings while allowing him to re-enter free agency in his early 30s.
Interest from Other Teams
Alonso’s free agency has attracted interest from several teams. The San Francisco Giants have been mentioned as a potential suitor, given their recent efforts to sign top-tier free agents. However, Oracle Park’s reputation as a pitcher-friendly stadium may deter power hitters like Alonso.
The Los Angeles Angels reportedly offered Alonso a two-year, $50 million deal, which he declined. Alonso and his agent, Scott Boras, are believed to be seeking a higher annual value, potentially around $31 million per season.
Fan Reactions and Future Outlook
Fans are divided over Alonso’s contract rejections. Some believe he is overestimating his market value, while others feel the Mets should make a more substantial effort to retain their homegrown star. Alonso’s consistent performance, including averaging nearly 38 home runs over his first six seasons and his durability—missing only 24 games in that span—underscore his value.
As the offseason progresses, the outcome of Alonso’s free agency remains uncertain. The Mets have made roster moves, such as signing Jesse Winker and A.J. Minter, and are preparing younger players to potentially fill the first base position. Alonso’s decision will significantly impact the Mets’ lineup and could influence the dynamics of the National League in the upcoming season.