BREAKING: New Orleans Saints Swap Controversial QB Derek Carr for “OVERPAID” $160M NFC QB in a New Trade Proposal
The New Orleans Saints are reportedly exploring a blockbuster trade that would send quarterback Derek Carr packing in exchange for another high-priced signal-caller from within the NFC. With Carr’s tenure in New Orleans under scrutiny after an inconsistent first season, the front office appears to be considering a fresh start at the most critical position on the field.
A Disappointing Year in New Orleans
Carr, who signed a four-year, $150 million deal with the Saints in 2023, was expected to stabilize the quarterback position after the post-Drew Brees era struggles. However, his first year in black and gold was anything but smooth. The veteran quarterback posted respectable numbers—3,878 passing yards, 25 touchdowns, and 8 interceptions—but his leadership, decision-making, and chemistry with the offense came under fire. Critics pointed to his struggles under pressure, inconsistency in critical moments, and a lack of connection with key weapons like Chris Olave and Michael Thomas.
Despite boasting a strong defense and a talented supporting cast, the Saints finished with a mediocre 9-8 record, missing the playoffs once again. Now, with the franchise at a crossroads, rumors are swirling that the Saints could move on from Carr and roll the dice on a different high-priced quarterback.
The Proposed Trade: A Swap of Expensive QBs
According to league insiders, a potential deal could involve the Saints trading Carr to another NFC team in exchange for a quarterback who has also been labeled as “overpaid” in recent years—Dak Prescott of the Dallas Cowboys.
Prescott, currently playing under a four-year, $160 million contract, has been under intense scrutiny in Dallas. While he has put up strong numbers throughout his career, his inability to lead the Cowboys deep into the postseason has raised questions about his long-term future with the team. After yet another playoff disappointment in 2024, Cowboys owner Jerry Jones is reportedly open to making a bold move at quarterback.
This potential deal would essentially be a swap of quarterbacks with massive contracts—Carr heading to Dallas, while Prescott takes over in New Orleans.
Why This Trade Makes Sense for the Saints
If the Saints were to acquire Prescott, it would be a signal that they are not content with mediocrity. While Carr has been serviceable, Prescott offers a higher ceiling in terms of playmaking ability and mobility. Over the past few seasons, he has consistently ranked among the top quarterbacks in passing yards and touchdowns, but his struggles in big games have been a major point of contention.
For New Orleans, the move could provide a fresh start at quarterback without the need for a complete rebuild. Prescott, who turns 32 this year, still has several prime seasons left and could benefit from a change of scenery. With weapons like Olave, Rashid Shaheed, and a strong defense, the Saints could provide Prescott with an environment where he can thrive.
Additionally, head coach Dennis Allen and offensive coordinator Klint Kubiak may feel that Prescott is a better fit for their offensive system. His ability to extend plays and push the ball downfield could open up the Saints’ attack in ways that Carr struggled to do.
Why This Trade Makes Sense for the Cowboys
From Dallas’ perspective, moving on from Prescott would be a massive shift, but it might be necessary. Despite his statistical success, Prescott has not delivered when it matters most, with the Cowboys repeatedly falling short in the playoffs. If Jones and head coach Mike McCarthy (or his potential replacement) decide that a change is needed, swapping Prescott for Carr could be a way to reset without fully rebuilding.
Carr, while not as dynamic as Prescott, is a capable quarterback who could fit well within the Cowboys’ offense. With a strong running game, a dominant defense, and elite weapons like CeeDee Lamb and Jake Ferguson, Dallas wouldn’t need Carr to be a superstar—just a steady, mistake-free quarterback who can manage the game efficiently.
Furthermore, Carr’s contract, while expensive, is more manageable than Prescott’s in the long term. If Dallas is looking for more financial flexibility in future seasons, making this move could help them avoid being locked into another massive quarterback extension.
The Financial and Contract Implications
Prescott’s contract carries a hefty cap hit, but the Cowboys could structure the deal in a way that benefits both teams. The Saints would be taking on more financial responsibility in the short term, but they may see Prescott as a long-term solution.
Meanwhile, Carr’s contract would be more manageable for Dallas, potentially giving them room to re-sign key players or make additional moves in free agency.
Will the Trade Happen?
While this proposal is purely speculative at this stage, it is not out of the realm of possibility. Both teams are facing pivotal decisions at quarterback, and neither Carr nor Prescott has fully convinced their respective franchises that they are the long-term answer.
If the Saints believe Prescott gives them a better chance to compete in the NFC South and return to playoff contention, they could be willing to take on his contract. Likewise, if the Cowboys feel they have reached their ceiling with Prescott, a swap for Carr could provide them with a new approach without completely starting over.
As the offseason progresses, expect trade rumors to continue swirling around both quarterbacks. Whether this specific deal comes to fruition remains to be seen, but one thing is clear—the Saints and Cowboys could both be in for major changes at the most important position on the field.